Proprietary estoppel: promises about property and inheritance
Proprietary estoppel may apply where a person has been led to believe that they have, or will acquire, an interest in a house, farm, land or other property and, in reliance on that belief, they act to their detriment.
These disputes frequently arise from informal promises within families. Someone may have worked for modest wages in a family business, cared for a relative, spent money on a property, given up a career or made other important decisions because they expected eventually to receive the property or an interest in it.
The promise does not necessarily have to be made in writing or in formal legal language. However, there must ordinarily be a sufficiently clear assurance, considered in the context in which it was made. A person’s private hope or assumption that they will inherit may not be enough.
“All you see here and a great deal more will be yours”
Robert Smith Surtees illustrated this distinction in Chapter I of his 1865 novel Mr Facey Romford’s Hounds.
Facey Romford had decided that he would eventually inherit from his maternal uncle and godfather, Francis Gilroy, a prosperous farmer and cattle dealer. Surtees says that Facey had “constituted himself heir” to his uncle. Believing that there was no need for him to continue working as a civil engineer, Facey gave up his profession and waited for his uncle’s property and money to come to him.
Surtees then writes:
“Gilroy never said in as many words to Facey, ‘Francis, my dear fellow, all you see here and a great deal more will be yours,’ but he always directed his letters F. Gilroy Romford, Esq., as if proud of the connection, encouraged him to look after his farm in his absence, to protect his Talavera wheat from Squire Gollarton’s pheasants, and see that he got a fair day’s work out of his women people at harvest and turnip time.”
The passage neatly illustrates a problem which often arises in proprietary estoppel cases.
Gilroy had not expressly promised the farm or his money to Facey. On the other hand, he treated Facey as closely connected with the farm. He encouraged him to look after it in his absence, protect the crops and supervise the harvest workers. Facey, meanwhile, had abandoned his occupation and lived in modest village lodgings while calculating how much his uncle might be worth.
Would that have been enough to give Facey a proprietary estoppel claim?
A hope is not necessarily a legal assurance
Facey’s first difficulty would be proving that Gilroy had given him a sufficiently clear assurance.
The words “all you see here will be yours” do not necessarily have to have been used. An assurance may arise from a series of conversations or, in an appropriate case, from words and conduct considered together. Family conversations about property and inheritance are seldom conducted in carefully drafted legal language.
However, the expectation cannot ordinarily exist solely in the claimant’s own mind. Surtees’s statement that Facey had “constituted himself heir” suggests that the expectation may have originated with Facey rather than with Gilroy. Surtees also says that each man trusted the other only “just as far as he thought right.”
Facey’s expectation may therefore have been no more than an optimistic assumption that he would inherit from a wealthy and apparently childless uncle.
Gilroy’s conduct would nevertheless require careful consideration. A court might ask:
-
Did Gilroy know that Facey believed he would inherit the farm or other property?
-
Did Gilroy say or do anything which encouraged that belief?
-
Why did Gilroy entrust Facey with looking after the farm and supervising its workers?
-
Did Gilroy know that Facey had abandoned his occupation because he expected to inherit?
-
Did Facey’s involvement in the farm indicate an intended succession, or was he merely providing occasional assistance for his uncle?
-
Was the alleged assurance concerned with a particular property or interest, rather than a general hope of receiving something under Gilroy’s will?
Silence or inaction can sometimes be relevant where an owner knows that another person is acting to their disadvantage because of a mistaken belief about their rights. But silence does not automatically turn another person’s private expectation into an enforceable promise.
When can proprietary estoppel arise?
Although each case depends upon its own facts, proprietary estoppel will generally require:
-
An assurance: the owner gives the claimant a sufficiently clear assurance that the claimant has, or will acquire, some right or interest in identified property.
-
Reliance: the claimant relies upon that assurance.
-
Detriment: because of that reliance, the claimant suffers a substantial disadvantage or makes a significant sacrifice.
-
Unconscionability: having regard to all the circumstances, it would be unconscionable for the owner to withdraw from the assurance or insist upon their strict legal rights.
These elements are not considered in isolation. The court examines the relationship between the parties, what was said and done, the context in which any assurance was given, the claimant’s conduct and the consequences of allowing the owner to withdraw from it.
What may amount to detriment?
Detriment can take different forms. It may include:
-
working for low wages or without proper payment;
-
giving up employment or career opportunities;
-
providing substantial care or domestic assistance;
-
spending money on the owner’s property;
-
improving, maintaining or managing a farm or family business;
-
declining the opportunity to purchase or occupy another home;
-
moving house or altering established living arrangements; or
-
making other important financial or personal decisions because of the expected property interest.
The claimant must show a sufficient connection between the assurance and the alleged detriment.
Facey might have argued that he acted to his detriment by abandoning civil engineering. Surtees says that he “thought there was no use in his toiling and slaving too; so he gave up the theodolite, intending to wait for his uncle’s shoes.”
His difficulty would have been proving that this was a reasonable response to something Gilroy had said or knowingly encouraged. Gilroy does not appear to have asked Facey to give up his occupation, and it is not clear that he knew why Facey had done so. Facey’s preference for hunting, fishing and dealing in horses may also have influenced his decision.
A person cannot necessarily turn an independently chosen way of life into legal detriment merely by saying that they expected to receive an inheritance.
How does this compare with Guest v Guest?
The Supreme Court decision in Guest v Guest provides a useful contrast.
Andrew Guest worked full-time on his family’s dairy farm for approximately 33 years. He received relatively low wages and did so in reliance upon assurances that he would inherit a sufficient part of the farm to continue farming. Following a serious family breakdown, his parents changed their wills and excluded him from the farm.
The courts found that the necessary assurance, reliance and detriment had been established. The Supreme Court then considered the appropriate remedy. Guest v Guest is reported as[2022] UKSC 27. [supremecourt.uk], [supremecourt.uk]
The contrast with Facey is revealing. Andrew Guest’s expectation resulted from assurances made to him over many years, followed by decades of poorly paid work on the farm. Facey appears largely to have “constituted himself heir,” abandoned his profession on his own initiative and indulged in increasingly optimistic calculations about the fortune which he hoped to receive.
What can the court award?
If proprietary estoppel is established, the court has a discretion to fashion a remedy which does justice in the circumstances.
Depending upon the facts, the court may:
-
declare that the claimant has a beneficial interest in the property;
-
order the transfer of the property or a share in it;
-
award the claimant a sum of money;
-
grant the claimant a right to live in the property for a specified period or for life;
-
grant some other right over the property; or
-
make another order designed to address the unconscionability.
The remedy is not automatic. Nor must it necessarily give the claimant everything which they expected to receive. The court will consider the nature of the assurance, the detriment suffered, whether the expected benefit is proportionate to that detriment and the practical effects upon everyone concerned.
What evidence will be required?
Proprietary estoppel cases depend heavily upon the evidence. This can be particularly difficult where the alleged promise was made many years ago or the person said to have made it has died.
Relevant evidence may include:
-
wills and previous wills;
-
letters, cards, emails and text messages;
-
diary and calendar entries;
-
bank statements and records of expenditure;
-
wage, employment and business records;
-
accounts concerning a farm or family business;
-
invoices for work carried out to the property;
-
documents showing opportunities which the claimant gave up;
-
evidence from relatives, friends, neighbours, employees and professional advisers; and
-
evidence of the parties’ conduct over the years.
It is important to preserve original documents and electronic messages. A detailed chronology should also be prepared while conversations and events can still be recalled.
Advice on proprietary estoppel claims
A long-standing expectation of inheritance is not necessarily enforceable. The important questions include:
-
What precisely was said or done?
-
Who made the alleged assurance?
-
What property did it concern?
-
Was the assurance sufficiently clear in its context?
-
Did the owner know how it was being understood?
-
What did the claimant do in reliance upon it?
-
What disadvantage or sacrifice did the claimant suffer?
-
Would it now be unconscionable for the assurance to be withdrawn?
-
What remedy would it be realistic and proportionate to seek?
For me to advise whether proprietary estoppel may apply in your case, I will need to investigate the circumstances and the available evidence in more detail.
I advise on proprietary estoppel and related property and inheritance disputes in Weston-super-Mare, Congresbury, Clevedon, Bristol and throughout North Somerset.
Please contact me:
Laurence Holmes Solicitors
Telephone: 01934 853355